My favorite moment in the new Paper Mill Playhouse production of Once on This Island (book and lyrics by Lynn Ahrens, music by Stephen Flaherty) came when the star, Syesha Mercado, danced by herself. It felt so natural, so organic and from the heart, it lifted my spirits; I didn't want it to end. (It seemed utterly spontaneous, although of course it was choreographed—and choreographed well—by Bradley Rapier.) My second favorite moment was when young Courtney Harris danced; again, I wanted the moment to last longer. The production has some fine singing. I loved Aurelia Williams's generous rendition of "Mama Will Provide" and Adam Jacobs' sgorgeous "Some Girls." And the whole ensemble put over quite well "Some Say." Director Thomas Kail has gathered together a talented cast. But I find this 90-minute musical to be rather slight—pleasant, and at times charming (with the spirit of a folk tale or fable), without ever being compelling. I've never found the story (adapted from the novel My Love, My Love by Rosa Guy) particularly satisfying. A peasant girl saves the life of an upper-class man, whom she loves; he marries a woman from his own class; the heartbroken peasant dies.... If you're looking for a really happy ending, or a hero who learns and grows, look elsewhere. There are some very appealing songs–as you will find in any Flaherty & Ahrens show. They're wonderful songwriters, but, for my own tastes, this is rather light entertainment.
Chip Deffaa
Cabaret Scenes
June 6, 2012
www.cabaretscenes.org
|
